Hi Mike thanks for your comments. I have read a number of posts on a number of sites with similar statements; however, I have also read a number of things that simply are not true of my dojo. My instructors are all B/W belt instructors, but they are open about their grade. All three are Brown Belts (2 3rd kyu and 1 2nd kyu). I suspect that the quality of the dojos does vary, but I can say that whenever I have asked a question about why we do something a particular way or what is the reason behind move x in kata x, they have always been able to give me an answer, or demonstrate the bunkai. I’m not going to blindly sing the praises of the organisation as a whole, but what I can say is that so far I have been impressed with: 1 - What I have been taught so far. 2 - The attitude of my instructors (even though they are not Dan grades). 3 - The atmosphere in my club. Is it too far fetched to think that it is possible for there to be some good instruction/instructors in a club with 40,000 members? Also I am grateful that they came 'knocking' as otherwise I doubt whether I would ever have had the nerve to approach a dojo myself. I am also amazed at the amount of criticism in general that I have read about GKR, much of it ill considered and badly argued. I have not read any posts yet by GKR members attacking any other forms of martial arts (although I am not saying they don’t exist, I just haven’t found them yet). From the little reading I have done about karate and its origins I understand that humility and respect for others are quite high in the principles? This doesn’t seem to stand very nicely with attacking other people’s arts (Mike this isn’t targeted at you specifically, it is just a general comment). Respectfully, D