bushido_man96

If he doesn't mind that you work in that other style, then he shouldn't mind if you test for black belt in that style.

Congrats, and good luck in your pursuit of shodan level!

Big congratulations, Bob! Way to go!

Even with the ones that didn't pass, it looks like you had a really good sized testing cycle, Bob. It would have been great to see it.

Welcome to KF! I'm sure you'll learn a lot here, and I'm sure you teach us something, too!

Congrats!

That's pretty cool. I hope I'm still kicking when I'm 84! Congrats to her!

Congrats! Like sensei8 mentioned, you've matured. Many view the rank of black belt as the goal when they start, but as they approach, they realize there is more in the offering, and it becomes another step.

Yes. But I think Boxing is still allowed.

I'd like to point out that no one here so far has mentioned any "get ripped quick" plans. The plans that have been mentioned have been plans used for years in the weight training community in regards to gains strength and size. The Starting Strength and Stronglifts 5x5 plans are all based on what is called linear progression, which is the best way for a novice lifter to gain strength. Once a novice lifter has come to the point where linear progression no longer works, its necessary to switch to an intermediate program like the Texas Method, or variants. Its also typical for those seeking strength gains to add weight along with it. The GOMAD diet, or creatine, or use of protein shakes are all good ways to gain weight to facilitate strength gain. There are varying opinions on the use of creatine, but milage will vary. Someone who starts out strength training can run on linear progression anywhere from 6 months to a year or more, depending on their individual capabilities. From there, one can run an intermediate plan from 2 to 5 years after that, depending on the individual. Once linear progression is over, its likely that the need for something like GOMAD declines, and that can be stopped in favor of the protein shakes. Stronglifts 5x5 tends to run longer on the linear progression plan than any of the others because of starting with the bar only on every lift except dead lift and barbell row, and only adds 5 lbs per lift per week. The others will progress linearly a bit more quickly by adding around 10 lbs per week, and starting with more weight than the bar. But, these methods both have the same common base that is rooted in building the foundation of strength.

Bob, I find my jumping ability has visibly waned, as well.

It sounds like your sensei is a pretty good man. I am not necessarily condoning the behavior of the dojo he is visiting. It sounds to me that the guy has a bit of an ego problem. But, in the long run of things, if going and learning is the goal, then the belt worn shouldn't prove to be an issue. Was the other sensei disrespectful? It sounds that way. Maybe that is his rule for everyone that comes in. Who knows? And everyone will make their own decision based on the situation at hand. After all, he did ask for opinions, and he got them. You've made yours, and others have made theirs. The discussion wouldn't be as rich if we all agreed.

I agree that perhaps finding an MMA gym may help expedite your goals, if MMA competition is your goal. If you find a good gym, you will have coaches at your disposal to teach all aspects of MMA competition, accelerating your learning curve. Doing Karate and then BJJ will be taking the long way around, and the younger you are when you get into MMA competition, then the longer your career can be. With that said, if Karate and BJJ are your desires, then go with them, and best of luck in whatever path you take. Welcome to KF, as well.

RIP.

Yeah, but it would be nice to see some rationale.

I agree, inasmuch, Karate WILL be treated as a sport in the Olympics because of its venue. Are you trying to say its not a sport, because it is an art?

I read your description, then looked a bit on youtube. The youtube videos are basically a cartwheel, but yours sounds different, but I have trouble seeing it.

My first time, I was pretty clunky and slow, and couldn't do too much. Not much has changed....

6/28/2013 Warmed up on elliptical for 10 minutes. Then did TKD workout: Blue belt review, doing Yul Gok and Jung Gun, along with the one-steps. I needed to repeat the one-steps, cause my brain went foggy. Also did Do-Kang 3, and Yoo Sin. Then a stretch.

Sure, it can happen. Happens to lots of people who drink alcohol, but that doesn't usually deter them from drinking more alcohol.Of course, some people don't tolerate milk as well as others. If you know this, then don't drink so much milk. There are other options.

Ah, ok. Thanks, Bob.

What would this technique be in English? Some kind of round kick, I'm guessing.

The thing with any style using forms, in my opinion, is keeping it all in perspective. I don't think that forms are the heart of Karate, or of TKD for that matter. The self-defense applications are. One can only learn so much from kata. What is more important than kata in any Martial Art, is having training partners to work on the applications with, to bounce ideas back and forth, and to make each other better.

The only Shotokan kata I would know is Naifanchi, or Tekki, Shodan.

It would be a great way to get comfortable with ground fighting, which is likely lacking in your Karate training. Learning how to improve position so that you can get up and use your striking skills is valuable information. I think it would be a great idea for you.