Patrick

Hello, KarateForums.com recognizes one member every month as the Member of the Month for their positive contributions to this community. The February 2006 selection is... Menjo. Congratulations!

Welcome to KF.

I believe has been talked to death and run it's course, so I am going to go ahead and close it. Thanks.

I'm going to go ahead and give this it's own topic. Thanks.

Very tough call, but I'm going with Pittsburgh for the Super Bowl. I think Seattle has the same chance, though.

Welcome to KF.

Welcome.

Hello, I believe this topic has run its course. Now on 12 pages, started about 1 year and 3 months ago. It is a mish mosh of subjects, including general Karate vs. TKD, which is not appropriate. This is not the place to discussion which martial art is simply "better" on a general basis. Thank you for visiting KarateForums.com.

You should go to a doctor.

Welcome.

Thank you for the submission.

Hello, We removed a post from this thread in error. It is quoted below and went before the last post. Sorry for the confusion. Thanks. What form of karate do you study? Also, are you aware that some Okinawan presentations of karate incorporate quite a bit of circular movement? I had the opportunity to have the system demonstrated to me, and this is not true. All movement in it is not circular. As well, it was indicated to me that the system has morphed over the years and that initially it resembled the crane-style kung fu, but then adopted quite a bit from capoeira. A badger comes from the United States, but if i were to name something such as, "badger style," it does not make the art American. Regardless, the lion is a feline, as is the tiger, panther, and leopard (variations of the feline animal style found in India and China). Kupigana was devised by an American and created within the borders of the United States. Therefore, the surrounding animals were that of squirrels, chipmunks, and pigeons. This is simply not correct. Well, this is a leading statement. First off, martial arts differ substantially, and also differ based on your perceptions of what the definition of 'martial arts' is. As to 'elite warrior,' if the practitioners of this style are not out there fighting hand-to-hand battles (real ones) on a regular basis, they are not warriors, nor are they all that elite. I believe it is inappropriate to argue that practitioners of this art are somehow warriors, while those studying all other martial arts are somehow not warriors. Well, most martial arts are not sport-oriented. As well, aikido is very much a spiritual art. As to 'spiritual warriors,' or 'warrior priests,' what is it that they preach? Btw, only William Nichols (the founder of this art) obtained this title, of which i'll cover later in this post. I'm assuming your teacher is the creator of this system. If not, then what follows is not relevant to these discussions. I do not question the experience and skill level of the originator of this art. Nor was i stating that the art he teaches is ineffective. Indeed, i really didn't call it fraudulent, although i suppose my posting of someone else's words about it being fraudulent could be considered an endorsement of such. Thus, i'll take ownership of this statement. Hmm, okay. Wrestling has its origins in Greece, bondo is from Burma with its roots in hung gar and a few other Chinese arts. Okay, he also studied judo (Japanese). Hmm, William Cheung instructs in wing chun. No other system. Okay, so he taught kung fu for six years, then created kupigana ngumi and started teaching the modified kung fu. It should be noted that during these six years in which he was teaching kung fu, he performed many exhibitions and participated in fighting matches in a world tour with the Oriental World of Self Defense, applying what he knew at the time... which was not African arts. He created the art, thus he controls the titles and rankings. I.e., he promoted himself. It has already been indicated, in other reports, that the majority of his travels between 1971 and 1978 were Stateside and Europe. Regardless, visiting a country and mingling with the natives does not give credence to his creating his own version of a martial art, and then calling it African in origin. In order to participate and win in the majority of these types of competitions, you essentially must apply Asian styles (katas are Japanese). Interesting, and impossible, since the last emperor of Ethiopia was put to death in 1975. Also, his obtainment of the 'warrior priest' title was received at an Akoben community exhibition, in the United States... and from an American organization closely associated with Mr. Nichols. I.e., again, self-promotion through cross-organizational ties. I'm curious as to what this has to do with the topic. I'm also curious as to what dialect/language you are referring to... since the literally thousands of tribes of the African nations each held to different languages or dialects. The study of African dialects is clearly not what is taught in kupigana ngumi (btw, was it in error that you've written the spelling of this art?). Indeed, i would not doubt that a few choice words are pulled out of one or two African-originated languages, so as to add flavor, and even that he presents African cultural education... but we're not talking about the trappings, we're talking about the martial art. Umm, Mr. Nichols was born in the United States, not in Tanzania. This is readily apparent by some bios written on him, as well as the fact he has none of the Makonde-type physical markings of tribesmen. Also, Makonde villages are run by 'hereditary' chiefs, based on matriarchal descent, so it is exceedingly unlikely that he would obtain such a status unless his parents were from Tanzania... which i understand they were from the U.S. Also, there is no indication of this in any biographical notes of Mr. Nichols, thus i'm placed in the unhappy position of claiming this as a falsity. Again, no indiction of this in any biographical notes. However, it must be noted that a Nana chief is merely a distinguishing status indicating someone who is level-headed and works to help a community in some manner. It doesn't necessarily hold to some 'grand' concept, and a donation to a village of food, clothing, livestock or even money could very well provide such a title. In this particular case, i would say it's possible, but again... does not somehow 'substantiate' the art he created a decade or so prior. Last, this and the previous claim are virtually impossible to verify. We would just have to take someone's word on it, now wouldn't we? I mean, these aren't titles that would entail receiving some sort of certification or government accreditation... so what's the point, except to add more trappings? Well, as i indicated earlier, Mr. Nichols created the style, and thus any federation based on the style. Any title he receives, is merely self-promotion. I'm sorry, but these things actually damage your arguments. Thank you for participating in the discussion.

Welcome.

Welcome.

Welcome.

Welcome.

Hello, KarateForums.com recognizes one member every month as the Member of the Month for their positive contributions to this community. The January 2006 selection is... AndrewGreen. Congratulations!

I think it's probably true that they both could have helped each other, etc. i.e., the more you use it (your body), the better you get at using it.

Male, 21.

Good for you, Chris.

Welcome.

Welcome.

Welcome to KF!

Hello, I just wanted to draw attention to the fact that we have reached 300,000 posts here on KarateForums.com! A big thank you to all of our loyal users and all staff members past and present that have worked to achieve our goals! Thanks for reading.

Belated Merry Christmas, folks.