
Nidan Melbourne
KarateForums.com Sempais-
Posts
2,605 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Nidan Melbourne
-
First off welcome to the forum! Have you tried looking up the person on google? Would you still be open to training with other schools or are you set on training with Robert?
-
Which Kata Best Demonstrate the Core of your Practiced style
Nidan Melbourne replied to Kanku65's topic in Karate
hmmm i feel like it is seisan is one the core kata from Goju-Ryu. Otherwise it is Sanchin is a core kata. -
I travel for work and want to take lessons
Nidan Melbourne replied to Grimmster's topic in General Martial Arts Discussion
That is unfortunate that you haven't been able to find a school that is understanding that you want to train but also that you travel for work as well. At my dojo we have a number of adult students that are in the same boat as you. But what we have as a membership option is lesson based and isn't time based. It is a 40 lesson membership so it is enough to cover all the lessons required to grade + a couple of lessons of the next rank on the proviso you pass your tests when they are scheduled and also when gradings are set. That membership was designed for those who are always very busy and can't always make it to the dojo every week. So less stress for the person. -
Martial myths
Nidan Melbourne replied to Spartacus Maximus's topic in General Martial Arts Discussion
Although i believe it depends on the brand of the belt itself. All the belts I have owned or currently own; the companies advise that you cannot wash your belt. But have seen some brands that are okay with you washing the belts. -
It is funny because as an Instructor I hate (tbh) it when people try and help when they actually don't know what they are talking about. Even a lot a students that are inexperienced I have noticed try and do it to the instructors. Although I admit that I do it, BUT only because I have many years experience teaching. But i listen to what they say and don't interrupt what they are saying. But chime in when information they are giving is actually incorrect or could be described in a way that more people understand. ALSO I do check with the instructor if it is ok if I do it, although I don't do this to sensei or a fill in head instructor (My sensei has been away on holidays in the US for the last few weeks)
-
No i don't have a weapons licence as I don't train in weapons with the exception of Balintawak Arnis (Sticks). But I do plan on applying for one.
-
Welcome to the forum njc81! Here in Victoria we have strict laws regarding all weapons. And requires permission from the police commissioner to own or import. http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?Document_ID=110
-
Why does Green Belt have the biggest drop-out rate?
Nidan Melbourne replied to Shotokannon's topic in Karate
I found it moderately hard but that is because it was the time i started taking karate seriously. But I have taught a lot of students over the years and a lot of them have quit because it is getting harder for them to pass tests. Especially when they start failing more and more because they aren't using their hips correctly and not doing kihon correctly. So they get disheartened when they realise they can't cruise through the grades like they used to. As green belts in my dojo is 5th kyu so the middle belt. We expect them to perform all techniques + kata that are up to their rank to a high standard. -
Belt tests...too often.
Nidan Melbourne replied to FangPwnsAll7's topic in Share Your Testing, Grading, or Promotion
That's how my old school did it. In my opinion that is excellent for the kids, it gives them a sense of achievement rather often and keeps them striving to move forward plus it doesn't drain any wallets! Now, my school ran $200 for dan gradings, but that did include registration with the national governing body, we tested in a hotel conference room, so it covered the cost of that, and also it covered expenses for the board members including the founder of our system.. All in all, it is terribly steep but when you think of where the money goes it makes sense.. I want to say the gup gradings were $35, I could be wrong it's been a while since I did one of those. When I look back at my school I think that sometimes it was a bit of a mcdojo but for the most part I think it was on the up and up. We graded every 3 months and if you were ready and your time in rank was satisfied you could test at each one, that's how I moved up so quickly. I also attended classes 6 days a week, so I was definitely prepared when it came to the grading cycle. I think that rapid advancement of some sort is needed with younger practitioners, hence why I am a big fan of the colored stripes between gradings, it really makes you feel like you're doing something. Now the way that I would do it personally would be to have around 10-12 ranks for juniors and also add the colored stripes, probably grade every 3-6 months and allow them to move up but at the black belt level I would have an age requirement and an extremely high standard. For the adults I would only have 3-4 belts total, I feel that they do not need the same motivation that the juniors would and therefore could be in the same rank longer, this would insure that their costs were kept down and also that when they did move up there would be substantial improvement, I would probably only grade them once a year.. At least that's how I see it but alas I do not have my own style, or even my own school. Why are your dan gradings so expensive? I'm curious to know the breakdown of the price for it? If there are more or less of people that are eligible to grade does that cost change? -
Belt tests...too often.
Nidan Melbourne replied to FangPwnsAll7's topic in Share Your Testing, Grading, or Promotion
What was the overall reasoning for students returning their belts after being promoted? I am guessing it is to save on costs of belts (for the operations front)? -
We Sent bushido_man96 a Sword
Nidan Melbourne replied to Patrick's topic in KarateForums.com Announcements
excellent work Bushido_man96! Patrick did you take a photo of the sword for us to see? -
Sorry moderators + Patrick if it is in the wrong forum. I am looking for some specialised training for tournaments in particular Kata from other styles of karate. As I am wanting to gain the experience and knowledge so I can try out for the state team next year. Does anyone in Melbourne Australia know anywhere I can train for that specialist training? Moderators pull it down if deemed inappropriate
-
Belt tests...too often.
Nidan Melbourne replied to FangPwnsAll7's topic in Share Your Testing, Grading, or Promotion
Tbh sounds like a belt factory -
Check out some of the pics that my partner took for me on the day https://www.facebook.com/liamohalloran/media_set?set=a.10153176810013142.1073741835.541368141&type=3
-
Sparring accident with a younger opponent
Nidan Melbourne replied to skullsplitter's topic in Health and Fitness
accidents happen and you have apologised profusely for it. It shows that you weren't out to hurt her. I have knocked out a few people before and i felt guilty about it for ages. They all have said that it was their fault because they didn't have their hands up -
Promoted to First Dan!
Nidan Melbourne replied to RAM18's topic in Share Your Testing, Grading, or Promotion
Congrats RAM18! that is a huge step. -
Which school was your student from? I might know which student you are talking about. I saw that Sensei Edji looked really annoyed that the setonline crashed and wasn't able to print off the running sheet and timetable of the events.
-
Just an update from yesterday: I had 3 rounds in my division. Round 1: Won 3 - 0 Won through means of Kiken. As my opponent did not show up Round 2: Lost 3 - 0 Performed: Seipai Round 3: Won 2 - 1 Performed: Suparempei - Made some very obvious mistakes because i was flustered. 1 official was Shito-Ryu and the other 2 were Shotokan. So I placed 3rd in the end.
-
In relation to space a Hotel is commonly really good but may be expensive. The tournaments i attend we use basketball courts and have our mats on top of that. As it is more cost effective for the organizer to use. You don't need a sanctioning body to organize the tournament, but it would be a good idea to so they can help you with potential places and to share with other schools in the area. Insurance is massively important especially since you will have kumite at the event. So be prepared to have that as the most expensive part of your day. Volunteers and Officials are going to be the most difficult to attain. So like i said before it is a good idea to have a sanctioning body because they will/should have a pool of officials. Formatting the day will be a busy/time consuming. what divisions are you going to have? what format of the rules are you going to use? Are you going to have repecharge? - Are you going to use the WKF (World Karate Federation) rules? Trophies, certificates etc should be taken into account for how many divisions you have. How much are you going to charge competitors to participate in the tournament and how much extra for extra events? At my VKL (Victorian Karate League) tournaments I compete at they are normally $75AUD for entry (includes 1 event) + $10AUD for any extra events. with the exception of the Victorian Championships which is $85AUD + $10AUD for extra events If you can get some sponsors that would be great and have them have a stall at the tournament so they can sell their product. Like how Arawaza was a major sponsor at the recent Senior World Karate Championships and all the competitors wore Arawaza Gi's and the kumite competitors wore arawaza mits and pads.
-
Question for Sandans and above
Nidan Melbourne replied to jaypo's topic in Share Your Testing, Grading, or Promotion
I am unsure on the specifics for his promotion as he trains at another dojo (my old one). But he has been contributing a lot back to karate for years now and brought up the standard of the dojos he taught at. -
'clunking' lower left back (sacrum?)
Nidan Melbourne replied to grenage's topic in Health and Fitness
To be safe go see a Physiotherapist or similar professional that can assist. As you may have an instability in your hips. Since you spend a lot of time at the desk you may have tight hip flexors in particular your left side. Which may cause that pain you are experiencing -
Advice needed from other instructors
Nidan Melbourne replied to LottieL's topic in Instructors and School Owners
Well it happens as well when roles are reversed where the female is in a position of authority and the male isn't I have seen it happen more often than when a male is in a position of power. Yes it occurs but not as often. -
Probably when my pants tore in the middle of my bjj class so i had to buy a new gi to replace them.