bushido_man96

If you have one style as a priority, there is nothing wrong with that. However, its important to respect what both instructors want and expect out of you in class, in regards to time committment and rank expectations. Just make sure you are on the same page with both of them as to your goals.

And those actions, in turn, create loyal customers. Good practices.

Great article, and I agree with most of your points. I think its important as an instructor to not stifle a student's curiousity about all things Martial Arts. I have noticed and written about the same kind of Martial Arts monogomy, and it is a real thing out there, and I can't stand it, either. You've got a great grasp of it here, and you do a great job of broaching the subject with your students. Keep up the good work!

Thanks for sharing your experience with us, Heidi. Very cool, and congratulations on this accomplishment! I imagine the real winners end up being your students. And it sounds like you've got Bob on board, so please keep us posted as to how you implement these things! It should be exciting!

For the practitioner, that's true. However, for the instructor, his/her obligations are to teach effective applied knowledge about said style of the MA in which they are teaching. Outside of what your post intents, that's quite true; it's a personal journey, even for the instructor. Instructors are obligated to teach!! Imho. I agree, Bob. An instructor has to realize that his or her journey also becomes entwined with other journeys, and although it shouldn't be an instructor's job to "convert," they do need to guide, which is very important.An instructor doesn't have the privlege to be selfish in his or her journey.

Some styles cling to the hierarchy more than others do. If you know that going into it, then you should respect what they do, and follow along. If its something that comes along as time goes by, then I could see taking issues with it.

I'd recommend going in with an open mind and an empty cup. Try not to think things like "we do it this way in Karate," and try really hard not to mention that in class. Just take the time to learn something new, and see where it leads you.

If things are already planned out, then I'd have to decline. If I have the time, I'd stop in for a watch a bit, but other than that, I'd have to hold my vacation plans. If I did have the time, then I would really consider it.

sure I don't understand why some think its a very big deal to learn online!! You have to keep in mind that there are a lot of old-school practitioners around that didn't have this kind of technology available when they began training. Therefore, its different, and its a change, and we some are more open to change than others. Like sense8 mentioned, there's the lack of feedback from a qualified, or at least experienced, teacher, and the secondary problem is that of rank, should it be sought out. If you choose not to try to attain rank, then that won't be an issue. But if you start doing on-line or video submitted testings for rank, that can be a different issue, as well. Credibility tends to come under question more in situations like that.

Great article, Bob! You've done a great job of laying this out for anyone wanting to start a pro shop. This one really stood out, and you are spot on with that. Customers can see this, and it says volumes about what you want to do.

Welcome to KF! Glad to have you!

I won't say that you can't learn a Martial Art online, but I will say it will definitely be the tougher road to hoe. You won't have any immediate feedback on what your doing, which, without any experience, is going to make it tough to figure out what changes you need to make on technique. Again, I won't say its impossible, but I will say it will be very tough, and you likely won't get great results out of it until you can work with someone that has some experience and can give you some feedback. Another issue is that Martial Arts is very much an interactive thing, and you really benefit by having partners to work with on technique and application. Without a partner to work with, progression is tough to judge, as well. I wish you luck on your endeavor, and strongly encourage you to look for some kind of school to train at. Just out of curiosity, why have you chose the style you have mentioned here?

Lots of good information offered here so far, so I won't rehash it. What I will suggest is that you start visiting these schools yourself. I'd do two visits, one with and one without the kids (go without first). Since your two kids are a consideration, then you want to check and see how each school approaches training for kids. See if they offer kids only classes, or mixed classes. See if they offer different curriculum for kids and adults. Check into all those kinds of things, and see which one is going to fit the needs of both you and your children the best. It would be easy for us to single out each of the styles you listed above, do a Google search, and then paste links next to each style talking about the theory of the style, technique, etc. But, what you will only get by visiting each school, is a feel for how the instructors teach, what their teaching philosophy is, and how they approach the classes. That's what you need to see when you visit schools.

Vacation for me is vacation. Its time with the family, doing family stuff. I don't worry too much about working out or anything like that. Its a good time to let the body rest and recharge.

You're welcome, ps1. That sounds like a heck of a task there.

Kudos to you, man! That's a tough run there. 8/11/2014 Monday While Belt Forms Workout: 1:20 - 2:00 pm. Front kicks: #1,2,3,4 from sparring stance and from front stance. Blocks and strikes: From sitting stance, a) high blocks; b) middle blocks; c) knifehand strikes; d) down blocks; e) middle punches, alternating 30 of each. Chon Ji hyung x2 Choong Jang hyung x2 Stretch

I'm confused as to how testing early saves you money? Aside from that, I don't think an instructor should be calling you out in front of a class in that kind of way, but that's just me. As for which school to choose, go to the one that you feel offers you the best training experience. Part of this decision is going to depend on what your goals are, and which provides you with the best way of attaining those goals. It may be a hard decsion, but I think you will make the right one. Best of luck, and let us know what you decide.

Thank you, Luther. Best of luck to you on your upcoming test! When I was in the ATA, the high chamber was how we chambered our side kicks. But my body doesn't like doing the kick that way, and the other chamber is the one I currently use, and I prefer it now to the other. Thanks for the elaboration here. I've also heard the C-step called a "half-moon" step. I like how you train your hip movement, especially to keep the power of the body in the strikes and blocks. The only thing I don't like is the stepping and landing, then pivoting into the strike or block in a separated movement. I think that takes away the point of the step. I think over time, its most helpful to time the step with the block or strike, which brings the body into play, and still using the hips, but the hip movement becomes much more subtle, in order to avoid the telegraph. Much like Harkon72 lays out in his post. I like the Wing Chun explanation and demo there. Very useful, I think. Reference the TKD video, I think its also important to take into account that he is demonstrating a board break, and when students do board breaks, they tend to focus and commit to the technique more than they would otherwise, even compared to the performance in a form. Great shares, by the way. Loving this thread!

Thank you, Bob. One of the nice things that the ATA does is they are always thinking of ways to improve and add to the student experience. When I was in the ATA, for instance, the World Championships only involved sparring at the finals at the end of the tournament year. Now, they've branched it so that an individual can win a world championship in forms, weapons, or sparring. That's one change I've seen, of many. Sometimes, I think they change or add things that they don't need to, but, on the other hand, they have lots of people constantly coming up with ideas, which at times will lead to some that not everyone likes. But they don't stagnate, that's for sure.

Thanks for this article, Alex. Its good to have some idea of what one could expect transitioning to an art like BJJ after spending time in Eastern styles. I'm in favor of the laid back type of atmosphere, and would like to see more of it, myself. Your explanation of what to expect while training in regards to the intensity levels, and the goal of rolling is very insightful, as well.

Great article, ps1. Very nicely laid out, explained, and I like the video demonstrations, too.

Interesting fact. I think that wearing the headgear, although perhaps preventing a knockout, probably leads to concussions just because they get hit in the head more over a longer period of time.

Those are interesting ways to get to the back. Nice position at the end, too. The part in the middle where you had the leg wrapped and then went to work around the head looked really ackward. I wondered about that, if it was some kind of stylistic change to make the form "their own" or something to that affect. Nice idea for the thread, too. I only have a few videos of myself I can think of off hand. Here is one where I was trying to expound with DWx on some different ways of executing the side kick, and why I like one way better than another: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFLHyCKGMGQ&list=UUYp41FDmb5wXCSMe_HkoEJw Here are a couple from my last testing. Sparring: (I was tired and out of shape, so probably doesn't look the greatest): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eD7WSCcX3SE&list=UUYp41FDmb5wXCSMe_HkoEJw Board breaking: (I really botched the spin heel kick): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wYR-mMZxU8&list=UUYp41FDmb5wXCSMe_HkoEJw And here's one of my getting choked out by Royce Gracie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7I0yotu_Zo&list=UUYp41FDmb5wXCSMe_HkoEJw

When you say C-stepping, I think of a few things: 1, you use it as a change of direction, dragging the back leg in the form of a C to follow an opponent or change direction and keep you front foot forward and stay focused on your opponent...or... 2, when you walk from stance to stance, your foot moves like a C, coming in towards the foot that is planted as it passes by, and then circles back out to its normal position when it sets down. Am I anywhere close?

Thanks for the info, tallgeese. I do like what I've done with Krav on the disarms, both hand gun and long gun. They are all close-quarters, so you are already in there when it starts. I just need to spend some more time with them is all. GRACIE also offers some interesting weapons retention, especially in the holster, that Krav doesn't have (or I haven't seen). I'm not familiar with the PPCT rentions or disarms. 7/28/2014 TKD Class: Taught, 6:00 - 7:00 pm. Basics, forms, one-steps, and some sparring. 8/4/2014 I was filtering through my MA notebook, and found some old "forms workouts" I put together years ago for working on belt-specific requirements when I was in the ATA. So, I'm going to try an experiment. I'm basically going to start myself over, and run myself on 2 month testing cycles, doing these workouts I put together years ago, but I'll do my current forms instead of the ATA forms. I have them set up for 6 days of the week, and should cover about 30 minutes per workout. Monday White Belt Form Workout: Front kicks: #1,2,3,4 front kicks from front stance, doing as a floor drill. Blocks and strikes: from sitting stance, a) high blocks; b) middle blocks; c) down blocks; d) knife hand strikes; e) middle punches; I did alternating hands, 30 total of each. Chon Ji hyung, 2 times, then stretched. TKD Class: Taught, 6:00 - 7:10 pm. Worked basics, reviewed forms from white belt to blue belt, then Gae Baek, one-steps from white belt up, then had them do some round-robin sparring. I had two high blue belts, one low blue belt, and two 2nd degrees in class tonight, so was able to really move along. I even hopped in with them on one-steps. 8/5/2014 Tuesday White Belt Form Workout: Side kicks: #1,2,3,4 from sitting stance, as a floor drill. Around 5-8 minutes. Front kicks: from natural ready position, alternatint front kicks to a target pad I attached to my standing bag, doing 20 per set, 4 sets, as high as I could, as fast as I could. Also sprinkled in some of my rehab exercises. Chon Ji hyung a couple of times, and stretched.