Do we need to ask permission?

[Shotokan-kez]

Yay...my first poll Thanks Bearich

As i explained in a recent thread. Students at our dojo have to get permission to train elsewhere...do you think this is right or wrong?

I personally don't mind because i don't think sensei would say no but i'm not aure i would like to be put in a situation where i ould have too

[Neo Dragon]

Thanks for starting this thread cause Im dealing with a situation like this. Ive trained in Karate and im almost at Black now and Im wanting to join a Judo school; but Im not sure if I should ask for my Sensei's permision. Im kinda woried about what he would say.

[cathal]

I am definitely saying Yes because if not a point of respect, the organization you belong to may have to take it into consideration when training in similar techniques. Legal issues such as insurance coverage may also come into play at some point as well.

[setboy]

Yes

[Myth]

I think I'd rather ask advice than permission, I would ask for advice, but I won't ask for permission. I'd probably follow the advice however.

[Jeet Kune Do]

Its better to learn more styles than just one

[karatekid1975]

I agree with Myth. I study Shotokan. I cross train in Jujitsu when my instructor can do it (he's a busy guy). Both sensei know I do the other art. They don't mind at all.

When I did TKD, my instructor didn't believe in cross training for his students, but he did it through out his life. So I did it anyway. Not out of disrespect, but if he did it, why can't we?

[Jiffy]

I'm with Myth on this one. I think you should at least advise your instructor what you are doing, even if you are not asking permission.

It is something that is of interest to them, and not disclosing as such is being a tad on the dishonest side.

[Brandon Fisher]

I say yes you should ask, if for no other reason out of respect for your sensei.

[dragonwarrior_keltyr]

I think it's more important for tradion and respect than anything else. Way back when you usually studied from one master and they were that, a master. So, I'd say yes, for respect of your sensei, and the art, ask.