
Hengest
-
Posts
32 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Hengest
-
-
I also would suggest not saying anything to the police, especially about being a MAist, until you have spoken to a soliciter!
Another good point. Many years ago I was working at a criminal law practice in Essex and I remember seeing one case up before the magistrates' where the victim of an attack took a roasting from the accused's counsel because he was a martial artist. Counsel wanted to argue that he'd provoked the attack in some way by dropping into a stance, or demonstrating a technique or just talking about his MA experience around his attacker! So perhaps it doesn't pay to mention your MA experience at all, whichever side of the fence you're on in a physical confrontation.
-
The only problem is with the legally. If you can prove that they initiated the attack you will have no proble. But how do you even start to prove that? A lot of fights are caused by alcohol causing people to be lairy. All the police will see are another two drunken people having a Saturday night brawl.
The best way to try and convince bystanders (and therefore potential witnesses) is by keeping passive body language; also serving as a tool in your fighting armoury as your opponent may underestimate you. The other suggestion is to put up a "fence" and to use verbal commands such as "Calm down I don't want to fight." Unfortunately in the real world his drunken mate has probably sucker punched you in the back of your head by now anyway!
Technically, in the UK at least, you're within your legal rights to strike first providing that you were placed in fear of an immediate physical attack and you use reasonable force. However, I do see what you mean in that practically speaking you may have problems convincing the police of your defensive action. It doesn't help that many police officers aren't aware of the actual legal situation. So I would add to the excellent points you made that its a good idea for people to actually learn the legal position (preferably word for word) and, should you be called upon to make a statement to the police, phrase it in those terms.
-
all i am saying is ,if we practice a defensive art like karate why not planning our fights defensively.
To me, a pre-emptive strike is a defensive action. Just because my reaction to a confrontation didn't include a block, doesn't mean I wasn't acting defensively, morally or legally.
-
i could see most of you will attack first, but still i feel confident to accept an attack
I don't think it's really about whether or not you have confidence in your defensive skills. It's more about adopting a strategy that is more likely to ensure you walk away from the confrontation.
What if I were to wait for the attack but instead of receiving the expected haymaker, I get a Glock pointed at my nose? At times like that you're going to wish you'd hit first and made a break for it.
Actual confrontation is a highly variable, unpredictable business and it doesn't pay to wait around and see what happens, cos you might just have waited a little too long...
-
What style are you looking at?
-
Personally, once I feel that an attack is imminent, I'll hit first. I've found from my own experiences that this is a much less dangerous way to deal with a situation and, contrary to popular belief, isn't against the law in most westernised countries.
List all martial arts
in General Martial Arts Discussion
Posted
Sorry. I was bored and got a bit carried away...
Aikido
Aikijujutsu
Amateur Wrestling
American Kickboxing
Archery
Arnis
Bando
Banshay
Baratero
Bartitsu
Bastone
Bata
Bersilat
Bojutsu
Boxing
Brancaille
Canne
Capoeira
Chausson Marseilles
Choson Do
Chuong Nhu
Collar & Elbow Wrestling
Collegiate Wrestling
Cornish Wrestling
Cumberland & Westmoreland Wrestling
Danmye
Devonshire Wrestling
Draka
Dumog
Escrima
Fencing
Freestyle Wrestling
Gicheon Mun
Glima
Gouren
Grand Baton
Greco-Roman Wrestling
Haidong Gumdo
Hanbojutsu
Hankido
Hankumdo
Hanmudo
Hapkido
Hisardut
Hojojutsu
Hojutsu
Hwa Rang Do
Iaido
Iaijutsu
Ishinage
Jailhouse Rock/52 Hand Blocks
Jeet Kune Do
Jodo
Jogo Do Pau
Jojutsu
Judo
Juego Del Palo
Jujutsu
Jukendo
Kaikenjutsu
Kajukenbo
Karate
Kendo
Kenjutsu
Kenpo
Kickboxing see American Kickboxing, Muay Thai, Savate
Koppojutsu
Krabi Krabong
Krav Maga
Kuk Sool Won
Kun Gek Do
Kung Fu
Kung Sul
Kusaribojutsu
Kusarijutsu
Kwonbop
Kyudo
Kyujutsu
Kyuk Too Ki
Kyushojutsu
Laamb
Lancashire Wrestling/Catch-as-catch-can
Lethwei
Lua
Lucha Canaria
Lutte Parisienne
Maculele
Mau Rakau
Muay Boran
Muay Thai
Naban
Naginatado
Naginatajutsu
Ninjutsu
Nippon Kenpo
Panache
Pananjakman
Panantukan/Suntukan
Pankration
Purring
Qwan Ki Do
Ranggeln
Sambo
San Shou/Sanda
Sasumatajutsu
Savate
Schwingen
Scottish Backhold
Ship Pal Gi
Shootboxing
Shootfighting
Shorinji Kenpo
Shurikenjutsu
Sikaran
Silat
S'istrumpa
Sojutsu
Sports Chanbara
Ssireum
Stav
Stockfechten
Suieijutsu
Sulkido
Sumai
Sumo
Systema
Taekkyon
Tae Kwon Do
Tae Soo Do
Taihojutsu
Tang Soo Do/Soo Bahk Do
Tankendo
Tanjojutsu
Tantojutsu
Tekkenjutsu
Tenarashijutsu
Tessenjutsu
Toamijutsu
Uchinejutsu
Viet Vo Dao
Yabusame
Yagli Gures
Zipota