Wastelander

I suspect that many of them do not do this on purpose--they have simply researched things so in-depth, and have explained them so many times, that they try to find ways to explain that they find interesting. Of course, there are still plenty instructors out there who use big words and complicated phrasing to make themselves feel smarter. The trick is figuring out which is which. Usually, the first group have something valuable to teach, and the second group want you to believe they have something valuable to teach.

Welcome to the forum! I actually just received my shodan ranking in Shorin-Ryu this past weekend, and I tested along with a dedicated 16 year old. I have been training for 8 years, and he's been training about that long, as well--if not a little longer. In my opinion, if your instructor believes you have what it takes, and you can pass the test at 16-17 years old, then your rank is just as legitimate as someone passing it when they are 18 years old. The fact that your instructor made you wait as long as 9 years before testing is a pretty good sign that he doesn't promote people lightly. Congratulations on passing your test, and enjoy your training!

Welcome back to karate, and welcome to the forum!

My primary concern is durability. I would really like a heavyweight gi made of 100% hemp, but nobody makes one--I have a lightweight hemp gi that I had someone make (didn't turn out that great, though), and a hemp jujutsu gi that I love (but it's shrunk a bit too much). Hemp is 4 times stronger than cotton, antimicrobial, provides UV protection, and is easier on the environment, so I just see all kinds of benefits. As far as cut goes, I'm partial to an "Okinawan cut," which isn't an official thing. Basically, though, it's a longer jacket (about mid-thigh) with 3/4 sleeves and pant legs.

It looks like the Tokyodo SP-1000 is a cotton/polyester blend. They do that to make the gi look nicer, because it doesn't wrinkle and crease as much as a 100% cotton one. I don't have any experience with that brand, specifically, and have always bought 100% cotton dogi, but I imagine it would be fine.

I'm afraid it depends on the brand. Some brands call their heavyweight gi "Shihan," while some have different fabric blends for their regular heavyweight and their "Shihan" gi.

Hello everyone, A friend of mine introduced me to the YouTube Channel for a Yin style Bagua group that has been uploading a lot of material over the past week from a training camp they recently did. I found the videos to be very interesting, and there were a lot of techniques with similarities to karate. Since some of you might find it interesting, I thought I would go ahead and share it here, as well. Enjoy! https://www.youtube.com/user/YSBinternational/videos

No, everyone is not rich--those brands are simply much cheaper in Japan, because they are Japanese companies. Most of the people I know that live on Okinawa have bought every belt (white through black) from Shureido, which is a top brand, as well. Whenever people I know travel to Japan and Okinawa, they always bring back uniforms and belts because it's so much cheaper.

If you are expecting to be moved by the military soon, then I don't see any point in trying to pick up a new style in your current area. You likely won't be around long enough to develop a good base in it, and it will just confuse your Matsubayashi-Ryu unless you devote a great deal of time to replacing your Matsubayashi-Ryu habits with Shotokan habits. Personally, I think you are better off practicing what you already know--if you have the time to consider joining a new club, you have time to train on your own, and if you love it as much as you say, that shouldn't be a problem. All that said, it probably wouldn't hurt to go in and train with them a bit, now and then. Not to pick up their style, but to get motivated to train harder, and get some partner work in. Maybe they have sparring classes you could come to, which would be less style-specific.

Thanks for the support, everyone! Yesterday was a long day, and I'm sore all over, today, but I passed! http://s10.postimg.org/4noq0bry1/noah_sensei_poage_2.jpg

Competition gets you amped up and floods your body with adrenaline and endorphins, so you're partially numb. Sparring is nowhere near as high-stress, so you feel those kicks and punches a lot more. Honestly, we only spar medium-contact or less, and save heavier contact for competition--it cuts down on injuries, and gets more people to spar more often. I'm not terribly fond of sparring, myself, but I understand its value, so I do it anyway.

My Sensei likes cross-training, and advocates it, but if you are going to be doing it consistently, it's best to wait until you have a solid base in our style. We've had some people who tried taking our style and a different style, consistently, at the same time, and they just got confused

My old instructor favored Tigear shin guards, and I've heard that Windy makes some excellent ones. I just use Shockwave shin/instep pads, which are just enough to take the edge off.

That's really more of an instructor preference than anything. I've heard of some schools drilling you on basics for months before starting a super-simplified kata, and then other schools throw you into kata from day one. And that's regardless of style! Your best course of action is just do your best at keeping up and learning the new material, and don't dwell too much on "how we did it in Uechi-Ryu."

Very important stuff--thanks for sharing!

I don't believe that push-ups are any harder on your body than planks, if you are doing them properly. That said, my Sensei actually hasn't written up any of the fitness/strength requirements, so we have no idea what is going to be asked of us when we test. It makes things interesting

Thanks for sharing this article!

We don't do any in-house events with our adults, but various parents and students will, occasionally, host parties at their homes. These tend to go over well with everyone--the kids come over and play until they are worn out, and the adults eat/drink/talk until the wee hours of the morning.

The Pinnacle is, essentially, the "bible" of Shuri-Ryu and its off-shoots. I don't have the book, myself, but I have copies of some of the sections, and I know several people who have it. As far as I know, you have to go through Roberta to get copies at a reasonable price, these days, but I don't know how much she charges. She is also notorious for being difficult to get in touch with, so you may have better luck asking someone who has a good relationship with her to call for you. Personally, my opinion of it is the same as ps1's. That said, if you practice Shuri/Shorei/Shorei-Goju-Ryu, it's pretty much required reading. The vast majority of schools in the Trias lineage follow that book to the letter (depending on the version they have). My old Shuri-Ryu instructor was actually so adamant that the style shouldn't be changed that any time someone asked him to get them a copy of the Pinnacle, he would order it and then go in and edit out the changes made after the last edition that Trias wrote.

Well, everyone manifests their art a bit differently. This is how my instructor teaches it, and how I try to implement it. Mechanics - Relaxation, speed, torque, and body weight. Strategy - Avoid/enter at angles, control the limbs, disrupt balance, strike vulnerable targets. Tactics - Distracting strikes (elbow to the body, kick to the leg, slap to the face, etc.), tuidi, power strikes (forearm to the neck, knee to the head, etc.), and takedowns (admittedly, I tend to put more emphasis on this aspect than my Sensei does).

Things vary, but our official requirements are: Time in grade (depends on the rank being tested for) Teaching hours (if testing for brown or black belt rank) Basics Self defense techniques Partner drills Kata Kumite You are also quizzed on karate history, orally, but we don't have to write papers. You have to know the Japanese terminology for pretty much everything, and have to be able to explain how certain things are done. The difficulty of all these questions varies depending on your rank, of course.

Thanks for the support, everyone! Part of the reason I'm so nervous is that I know it will be a very difficult and demanding test, and my health has been quite poor since November. I've been dealing with unexplained motion sickness and fatigue since then, and no doctors have been able to figure it out, so I haven't been able to train the way I feel I need to. Objectively, I know that I can only do the best I can do when the time comes, but I always put pressure on myself to do better. As far as what will be on the test, I know the curriculum items that will be included: 66 kihon waza 43 self defense techniques, demonstrated in the air and on an attacker 19 kata, and applications for them 7 yakosoku kumite drills, both attacking and defending roles There will also be questions on history, philosophy, details of movements and body mechanics, etc. My Sensei also knows that I know kata outside of the curriculum, and may ask me to demonstrate them, along with possibly asking me to demonstrate applications. I suspect he will ask me to do a kobudo kata, as well. I've never seen one of his shodan tests, before, so I really don't know what to expect--the only thing I have to go by is the one shodan test I was an attacker for at my old dojo. I expect to be nitpicked on form until it drives me crazy, made to do things over and over again for minute mistakes, and asked to do strange things (like backwards kata with push-ups every three moves, or something), all to try and make me give up. Then, of course, I have to spar everyone on my testing panel after everything else, when I'm completely exhausted.

ps1 is absolutely correct--if you're going to try to research this, you are going to have a hard time. In addition, different styles use slightly different body mechanics, so if you end up pulling information from people who do things differently, your instructor may tell you that your paper was wrong. And that's just for power generation! Snap is a totally different can of worms. You're going to have to define "snap," for one thing--there are different characteristics that martial artists might call "snap." One kind of snap might be good, and another might be bad, depending on who you ask. Your best bet is really going to be studying how your art does it, and explain that to the best of your ability. You said "in martial arts (specifically, karate)," but that is extremely vague when it comes to the topics you have to cover. If you feel you need more information on how your style does things, you could try reaching out to other people who practice it and ask them. We are happy to help people on this forum, but this is going to be a pretty tough one!

Welcome back to the forum, and karate! Which "Okinawan Shorei-Ryu" do you practice? There is Shorei-Ryu that is headquartered in Okinawa, that I am aware of, and there is the "Okinawan Shorei-Ryu" that came from Robert Trias, before he changed the name to "Shuri-Ryu."

I don't set aside time for it, but I do at least a little training every day, and it's usually scattered in bits and pieces throughout the day. A kata here, some bagwork there, things like that. I try to always work Naihanchi Shodan, at least, every day, and rotate through my other kata. I do, occasionally, do a longer 1-2 hour workout, but they aren't planned in advance.