sensei8

Solid post!! To the bold type above... You've given me a chance to quote my most favorite quote...Proof is on the floor!!

I understand!!

Well, you ARE still an advanced kyu; no matter how long you've been not actively learning/training. You might be rusty, but in time, that rust will not be a factor. Now, for tournament sakes, most tournaments want to know how long you've been training. Rank is a concern, but the reason for asking how long you've been training is give them a better understanding. Because, one Ikkyu isn't the same as another Ikkyu for many reasons. Therefore, tell said tournament that you're advanced AND tell them it's been X many years since you've actively trained. Then, they'll place you in a division that's appropriate as far as they're concerned. Now, for learning/training sakes. Restart as a Jukyu/Beginner, and then the CI will determine your current rank for the time being. Hang in there!! You'll be fine.

Solid post!! One watching YouTube and the like, can tell if said person on said video is an instructor or not, and if said instructor is good at teaching. Not all BB can teach. I'm not saying that all videos are made for the purposes of teaching/learning. Most videos, imho, are more of a reference to some, and some just for fun.

Possibly it's time to just be a practitioner and not an instructor until things change.

Could be hard/difficult to prove/defend those parameters of force because how one defines each will differ from person to person. Proving is convincing ones ideologies, and at times, that's just not that easy. However, at times, it can be just that easy. Depends on the courts!

First of all, Welcome to KF. Glad to have you!! Imho, that was a good 2 cents worth; solid post!!

In Shindokan, we've the typical Okinawan weapons at our disposal. Our Kobudo is in addition to our empty hands. Soke spoke about how "Karate-do is first, before Kobudo, but they're both equals in temperance."

Imho, A Sensei shouldn't demonstrate like ways of students that aren't model students. No. Counsel them in private so that said student understands all expectations and that there's no ambiguity whatsoever. Student still doesn't want to comply with said expectations, then suspend said student. Student is then allowed to return, and then still continues in a disrespectful manner, then expel, thus, ban said student. Resistant training is very important, but the training is meant to also be safe for all before it can be effective. When said student acts rogue on the floor, that's no reason to copy said students actions to show said student what it feels like. It borders on abuse from said Sensei. That to, should never be tolerated. Take the appropriate and consistent measures towards said student(s) when said student(s) try to dictate anything, and I mean anything, on the floor. The floor is for everyone, but when things like this are happening on the floor, that's when the floor becomes mine, and mine alone. I will not share my authority with any said student that's not meeting said expectations. This said student should be dealt with professionally, and no other way. For a Sensei to lower themselves to the inappropriate actions of said disrupting student(s) to teach them a lesson, and/or to show them what it feels like isn't commendable at all. Especially in todays world. How it was done yesteryear, isn't how it should be done today! Not with the laws of the land today. Legal law suits and the like are being handed out like free candy at a carnival. Discipline is one thing, but an overall disregard towards an instructors obligations and oath, no matter how silent or how loud they might be, which is to protect ALL students, no matter what. Discipline and how it should be handled is a thin line. One that mustn't be ignored at all, but understood that what stands on that said thin line, is respect. And if a student shows no regards and/or respect, the Sensei should show even more respect and/or regards to said student. We've, instructors, an obligation to our students to teach and guide them in a respectful tone at all times. Counsel, then suspend, and then ban, if need be, however, it must be consistent across the board. From day one, let said student(s) know what's expected of them and what's allowed and what's not allowed, and let there be no misunderstanding. The Sensei is always the boss both on the floor and off the floor at all times. Imho.

In my opinion, Your Hombu has no valid reason(s) to not provide you a copy of your rank certificate. To me, it's an absurd absolute because it's YOURS, and not the Hombu's. Yes, the Hombu is the governing body and it does "manage" all important documents, but the word "manage" doesn't mean "ownership" of said documents. Not at our Hombu!! Yes, there's a very small administrative fee that accompanies said request, but a rank certificate isn't the property of our Hombu. For me, it's low and cold to refuse said request. Our Legal Team would be all over this, and quick!

Hopefully you get better soon Thank you Safroot!! Worse thing about a cold is that my nose is raw from all of the blowing in a aloe soaked napkin; stupid runny nose!!

That's no good! Get well soon!Thank you Zaine!!

Now that's cool!! That's what I've been asking, thanks!! Anymore, anyone?!?

OMG, what part of the body doesn't get hurt from time to time, if at all? Groin Muscle strains Sprains Breaks Dislocations Abrasions Teeth Mouth/lips Eyes Head Ears Knees Fingers/Thumbs Jaw Well, the entire body is subjective to receiving injuries in just about any part of the body. Injuries don't have to happen while training in the MA, but they do, and one can only do there best to avoid them. At times, we cause our own injuries for many reasons, and when we're not hurting ourselves, our training partners help us out in that area. Point to any place on your body. It'll either be hurt from time to time or it won't be as often, but somehow and someway, the body gets racked from time to time at no one fault; it just happens.

And if your gi doesn't shrink, or doesn't shrink enough, well, then get out the sewing kit and make it to your specifications. OR...send it back to the company you bought it from so that you can get a properly fitting gi. Nowadays, gi's are tailored for a many body types. In the days of old, gi's were in whole sizes, 1 - 6, so they either fit well or they just didn't.

Sorry that I didn't give you a better answer to your OP question, and that's because a long dissertation might've not been warranted and that is because everyone's personal opinions about MA philosophy would've been close, but not exact from one to another. Still, solid topic; thank you for starting it!!

South Florida. But winter is nothing new for me. Grew up part of my life in Iowa where we definitely got some snow. I remember early am kendo classes outdoors in Jan before school. If we had 14 guys in the club maybe six would actually show up. It was kinda rough. Yeah, I don't think I'd show up either because I don't want to test my MA mettle with the flu. I do like your outdoor training area; solid across the board!!

Do you mean to say that all Karate practiced currently is a hybrid of Shuri-te and Naha-te together, or that all Karate practiced currently is either a hybrid descendant of Shuri-te or a hybrid descendant of Naha-te? Two different interpretations of your statement... The latter interpretation. I wholeheartedly concur to the latter interpretation. The style I practice is a hybrid descendant of Shuri-te and Okinawa-te. Traditions rich, but as of late, it seems to me that the fast-food culture that we find ourselves in has possibly tainted those traditions of yesteryear for what appeases them nowadays. I'm cool with that because change is a good thing. However, to say that training in the old ways produces ineffective results compared to modern day training ethos isn't an accurate statement. However more, can't the two "traditional" training worlds of yesteryear and today be intertwined to produce effective results, thereby recognizing both training worlds as a good thing for a MAists betterment?? Imho.

Just when my back is slowly improving, I come down with the cold. Lots of rest, fluids, meds, and chicken soup. I'll not be at the dojo because I don't want to infect anyone. Good grief!!

Well, you DID IT!! Congrats, and well deserved.

How much does he need the sound of the crowds? How much does he need the approval of his peers and/or fans? I don't know if he'll ever come back, but how he answers the first question above, might tell us a lot about him both as a person and as a MAist. A lot of those in the spotlight truly miss the need to compete in front of the crowds. The crowd is a drawing factor, especially when you're at the top of your venue. Pro-Wrestlers come out of retirement because they miss the "pop" of the crowd. In GSP, I think it'll be the desire to compete and to test his own mettle. Imho, he's nothing to prove. Imho!!

Well, it wasn't without its moments, but I survived both classes. I'll not rush into a full teaching/training schedule as of yet because I'm not getting younger.

Thank you for your suggestion, and it's something that I'd consider.

Politics are only deemed negative when they get in the way of training. Politics are needed because they govern the checks and balances within said governing body. For a governing body to say that no politics exist at all, is not being honest with themselves, and their student body. I'd say for the most part, our positive politics greatly outweigh our negative politics. So, when I speak about politics in a negative tone, it's because it's distracting away from the training/teaching that's paramount to ones MA betterment. Change is inevitable, and politics, good or bad, are at the root of change, imho.

Sparring and self-defense aren't suppose to be the same. Your close range drill is excellent in demonstrating space management. Thanks for the videos!!