February 24, 201016 yr Has anyone ever made up a kata using two diffrent weapons, such as a kama and sai?
March 6, 201016 yr Anyone have any thoughts on this one?Thanks,Patrick Patrick O'Keefe - KarateForums.com Administrator Have a suggestion or a bit of feedback relating to KarateForums.com? Please contact me! KarateForums.com Articles - KarateForums.com Awards - Member of the Month - User Guidelines
March 6, 201016 yr Classically, there's the tinbe-rochin, the traditional Okinawan pairing of a small shield (archetypically made from a turtle shell) and a short spear. It's one of those strange little corners of kobudo.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q349Gt1gLlY
March 8, 201016 yr A sai with a kodachi? That'd be more than a little unusual because it'd be mixing historical classes of weapons, one a traditional Okinawan kobudo weapon and one a Japanese sword. It does make a certain amount of martial sense, however: there's a lot of mileage to be gotten out of the idea of a one-handed sword and an off-handed parrying weapon. It's terrain more thoroughly explored by Western than Eastern sword arts: if you're feeling particularly adventurous, you might even look into Rennisance-era main-gauche play for inspiration.
March 8, 201016 yr The closest we've come to that is experimenting using a sai AS a tonfa, and vice versa. (yech)Also, I guess I'd kinda think of eaku, nunti-bo, and to a lesser extent quwa and sansetsukon as having the qualities of two different weapons. Another would be chisi as it employs more empty hand techniques. Leaves fall.
March 16, 201016 yr At once? Nope! Other than the tinbe-rochin that Toptomcat mentioned. It [different weapons at the same time] could be doable until I picked up a weapon that required the use of both of my hands to wield it. Still, it's an interesting thought and the combinations are quite intriguing...which with my luck, I'd only end up hurting myself for one reason or another. **Proof is on the floor!!!
March 21, 201016 yr Author I talked to my Sensi and he said that you could us two weapons, like the sia and sword, or jo. and they might have done it historically.
May 21, 201016 yr It is common at our Blackbelt testings for sensei to hand a student a tonfa and a sai, or tonfa/sword, sai/kama,etc. and tell the student to perform a specific kata. The reasons for this are twofold I believe. One to demonstrate that the basic principles behind any weapon are generally the same, and two to test the students improvisation ability.I've welded two weapons of a different sort, and I've seen several people do it. It's all about the basics. If a blackbelt is easy to attain then you have to question the worth of the rank.
May 22, 201016 yr In eskrima there are several things that use a stick (rattan aaround 26" or so...) and a knife in the other...I don't really know them yet (too advanced for me)Also there is a whole style called espada y daga which is shield and dagger. A warrior may choose pacifism, all others are condemned to it."Under the sky, under the heavens, there is but one family." -Bruce Lee
Create an account or sign in to comment