Yes I think that kid may not have the maturity mentally to be a black belt. I mean kids under 13 (or maybe even 17) maynot be ready for given title black belt. Most people do just look at the belt and think they all done. I think that their need to be more requirement for becoming a black belt, because I heard situation where a black belt got beat by my friend who was a yellow belt and from the way my friend tell it, it sounded like the black belt had no clue what he was doing. Now that just not right, a yellow belt should never had that easy of a time defeating a black belt. Maybe their should be like a one year waiting period for instructors to take a look at the martial artist skill to see if he up to black belt level or something...