Dustin1978

Okay I have been reading up on the art via the web and I like how it is based greatly around a very passive attitude. My question is this. If it is 100 % defensive can it be adapted to be used in another way? Example..... I am at a party and some drunk idiot tries to start a fight with a friend of mine. My friend cannot defend himself and needs my help. The drunk guy has not physically attacked me but I want to help. A) Would stepping in and going "offensive" be wrong by aikido standards because I myself was not in any danger? B) Would aikido teachings help me in this situation? I understand it has a lot to do with not confronting someones oncoming attack directly but more to dodge and throw them off balance so is 100 % of aikido based on ONLY if someone is coming directly at you? Would I be able to use some of the arm throws or locks to go offensive so to speak to stop someone from attacking someon else? Sorry My posts always get so long.

yeah check them both out kinda goes without saying but I was just wondering what might be more suited for my goal. I realize I left this out in my first post I want to be envolved in an art that will prove to be effective on the street and in "real" situations. I DO understand that nobody can be an expert in a month or even years or decades or life times even but I want something that would be easier to apply quicker so I am leaning towards the Judo. ANyway just thought I would add that Thanks guys for any additional info. Also I still was wondering How exactly Judo Difers from TJJ. thankx for any info!

Okay guys and gals. As you may recall I was thinking of going to the traditional Jui Jitsu but in the new town I moved to the aprtment I ended up getting is WAY on the other side of town. A block from my place I have a martial arts center that teaches Aikido, Judo, and some form of karate. Anyway I do want to get into a grappling art so I am now leaning toward Judo BUT I am hoping it isnt more towards the sport aspect where ass they train ways to get points and not actualy joint breaking dislocating Street moves like the Juijitsu may have. Also I was told here that Aikido would most likely take at elast a year before it would be of any benfit in a "real" situation. Also The aikido From what I understand you kind of have to wait for someone to grab or strike at you to do much. But man the throws and joint locks look TIGHT in aikido. The Judo I am thinking would be better as it has offence and good defense. Does Judo have strikes like TJJ? Thanks all for advice!

The only difrence is BJJ took EVERYTHING IT IS from TJJ. They only learned a small portion of TJJ and then did expand on it but it is more of a sport version of TJJ. TJJ has strikes as well and also they take the time to teach how to fall properly and many other things before you start randori (free play) thus reducing injuries. BJJers boast how many people get injured in their gyms like this is some proof of their style being more "real". While it is good I will say that there are more injuries because they just let people enter off the street untrained just start going at it. And while yes it might help you learn quicker for a real fight I must say that if your brak your arm in the first month it is going to slow you WAY down in the learning process. and as far as BJJers going againt resisting opponents this is what TJJ is ALL ABOUT. Almost all belts (after the initial ones) the tests are free style wrestling to show you know your moves and your oponent is FULLY resisting. I know my spelling sucks but I just wanted to impart what little I know. Later

Thank you I will try it!

was that comment geared towards me and my defense of the art of Aikido while at the same time poking fun at the BJJers? or was it to the original guy saying Aikido was pathetic? Just want to know if I broke any rules

before you get all mad cavalera let me just say that yes all the gracies could wup me to a pulp (even though they swing liek girls) hehe I was just making a point

cavalera, Why would you make such a comment? That is highly disrespectful to those that DO practice Akido. I would hope that you might be more open minded in the future or at very least respectful of all arts. If you are so against all the other arts then why are you posting in General? Maybe you belong in the Jiu-Jitsu/Grappling Martial Arts Posting section. From what I have seen Aikido is a VERY impressive and fluid art. I do agree that it would be good to cross train to get some striking skills but you as a BJJ cannot critisize striking skills as all your gracies swing like girls in the ring. (last comment not meant to be disrespctful to women but you all know what I mean)

Hey guys and gals. Like you all probably know I have decided to take JuJitsu once i get moved up to my new location. From what I understand there is no solo forms such as there are in Karate or kung fu styles so how do they test? I am assuming it is some sort of wrestling (Randori)? If so is it against a person of equal or grater experience? Higher belt rank than yourself? Is it a full out free style match to see if you can execute the techniques you have been tought or is it simple performing the moves on a non resistant partner? I know there is some striking and so on but I do not think there will be any breaking in belt progression. Also is it usually up in front of the class all alone with everyone watching or is it usually a group test? The last kung fu school I was in was very easy because the Sifu would just watch and promote you to the next sash when he felt you were ready with no tests at all! Karate in my childhood days was also easy just perfoming the katas. Anyway Any advice would be great! Thanks Friends!

WOW i bet! Do you yourself have bad or no vision in one eye or are you saying you have trained with people who are lackign depth perception? I am not sure I would even attempt weapons training for fear of hurting one of my class mates. I mean chances are everyone will have bumps and bruises which is fine but I wouldn't want to break someones nose with a stick to the face Hmmmmm But weapons training would be fun!

If anyone figures out how to open and close poors on command let me know! I am sure it would work wonders on my acne and keep my skin looking healthy for years to come! And I could finally eat garlic and not stink!

Yes that is a very good point! I will obsess on my martial arts training! SOunds good to me You rock! Thanks much!

"WE HAD THIS GUY LIKE A PRETZEL ON THE GROUND" states judo team member Alleged carjacker Tyrone Hogan learned that you should be more careful when selecting mugging victims. Specifically, it is a bad idea to take on a group of able-bodied athletes and a very bad idea to take on a traveling judo squad. Furthermore, if you do so then you should be prepared to be forcefully restrained, bloodied, and doused with gasoline before being handed over to the cops. According to the Los Angeles Times, it all started at around 1:30 pm on Sunday, August 18th, when 20-year old Tyrone Hogan allegedly carjackaged a man and women outside their Hollywood-area home. After pulling the man out of their automobile, Hogan got into the driver's seat and drove off with the woman inside. After attempting to grab the woman's purse, officials say that Hogan then forced the woman out of the traveling car. He then pulled into a Mobil gas station to steal another vehicle. Unfortunately for Hogan, the beige minivan that he selected was occupied by the Florida International University Judo Team. Apparently lacking any form of common sense, Hogan asked a member of the coed judo team for money and then struggled with other team members as he attempted to gain control of the minivan. Several members then joined in "restraining" Hogan with what they called a "Boyd Hold." For his troubles, Hogan was bloodied, arrested, treated for minor injuries and is being held on $1.2 million bail. Blackbelt TV would like to remind other would-be carjackers that there are over 5 million martial artists in the United States and self-defense classes are at an all time high. Therefore, before you try to forcefully gain control of an occupied vehicle, make sure to first ask yourself as to whether you feel lucky.

well she used terms i was not familiar with. like asian words. she said that the BJJ creators stuidied the (somthing) and took from ti what they liked and only really studied the grapling. I am not too sure about the Aikido

From what the Sensei at The JuJitsu place said is that both Aikido and BJJ came from this particular art of JuJitsu. But I guess that is not to say that this style has ALL of what both those arts offer. From what she said was that BJJ took the training and specialized in only the grappling and they train almost no striking at all (if any) and also that BJJ schools do not teach the low level students how to roll and break fall properly and that BJJ school tend to have a LOT more injury in class. She Also said something to the affect of Aikido. While it may have come from this art it did specialize in the throws and so on so I am sure it does have al ot more power and specilization in the throws and joint locks and maybe redirecting power and the smooth flow and so on. I am thinking that the Danzan Ryu kodenken JuJitsu would be well rounded and cool for self defence though. I looked it up and it s recognized by all the authorities on the subject and the school in Chico is nationaly registered and it all looks very legit and non McDojo yeah right now the kuk sul do is out cause i think it is more of a striking art. but I am still up in the air between aikido and JuJitsu. Also can Aikido be used for the offensive? or is it PURELY defensive in nature? Like if I am in a situation where a guy is bigger than me and I KNOW for a fact he is going to swing sooner or later I would rather make the first blow and just take him out (if possible)