TKD or JKD?

[REYS77]

WHICH SHOULD I DO? AND WHY ?I AM NEW TO THE MARTIAL ARTS

[Martial_Artist]

TKD is an art. JKD is a philosophy. Take the art and apply the philosophy if you want to.

 

MA

[TJS]

neither

[REYS77]

why not

[larryjf]

Try and see which martial art is more in tune with your personality (look at a good number of martial arts, not just a couple). Then, go with the one that best suits you.

[IAMA_chick]

TKD works for me but you might want something else. tkd is 80% kicking so if you want that. it isn't going to help you too much in a real fight b/c kicking them in the head might not be an option. it is very fun for me but that might be due to the instructor and the people that i take class with. good luck with everything.

[TJS]

why not

 

because its very difficult to find a good JKD school since its really a philosophy

 

and TKD mcDojos run rampant..

 

but i was half kidding

[Lee]

If you're new then I'd say TKD. JKD is more of a philosophy/concept/method of fighting, not an actual style. Therefore in order to effectively use JKD you need to know a MA style to apply JKD's teachings to it. JKD is like spices to enhance the flavor, it won't do much to the chicken if you haven't learned how to cook a chicken yet.

[Karateka_latino]

Don't know... Visit the schools first. Almost 70% of all TKD Schools are Sport. If you want self defense, then that doesn't help too much.

 

JKD Is something good when you have been in the martial arts for a while.

[TheSod_88]

between jkd and tkd? answer: jkd. But i truly suggest neither!