luv2flyjrn Posted November 14, 2018 Posted November 14, 2018 Anyone running the wkf circuit? Are you finding certain types of kata more successful? Do you mix styles to perform what you feel is the best scoring version of the kata? Rank does not matter. If you can't learn from a white belt you are probably not deserving a black belt.
ineluki Posted November 14, 2018 Posted November 14, 2018 Anyone running the wkf circuit? Are you finding certain types of kata more successful? Do you mix styles to perform what you feel is the best scoring version of the kata?I don't anymore, back when i did, the clear favourite was Unsu.I recently came across this study though:http://imcjournal.com/index.php/en/volume-xviii-2018/contents-number-4/1390-top-level-karate-analysis-of-frequency-and-successfulness-of-katas-in-k1-premiere-league
wayneshin Posted November 14, 2018 Posted November 14, 2018 Anyone running the wkf circuit? Are you finding certain types of kata more successful? Do you mix styles to perform what you feel is the best scoring version of the kata?I just returned home from the WKF World Championships. I would estimate that Shito Ryu kata comprised 70 to 80 % of the Kata performed in the individual divisions. All four finalists (Male and Female) performed Shito Ryu. In the women’s final both did Chatanyara Kushanku. The Men’s were one Annan Dai and i think the other was also Chatanyara. There was far more Shotokan in the team events.
luv2flyjrn Posted November 14, 2018 Author Posted November 14, 2018 Anyone running the wkf circuit? Are you finding certain types of kata more successful? Do you mix styles to perform what you feel is the best scoring version of the kata?I just returned home from the WKF World Championships. I would estimate that Shito Ryu kata comprised 70 to 80 % of the Kata performed in the individual divisions. All four finalists (Male and Female) performed Shito Ryu. In the women’s final both did Chatanyara Kushanku. The Men’s were one Annan Dai and i think the other was also Chatanyara. There was far more Shotokan in the team events.Interesting no unsu from shotokan or gojushiho from goju ryu. I wonder if people are tired of unsu and superiempi. Did anyone try to cross style and run shotokan kata like unsu, then a goju ryu such as gojushiho, and a shito ryu kata? I wish I could find a list of all kata run like in the study posted above. Rank does not matter. If you can't learn from a white belt you are probably not deserving a black belt.
wayneshin Posted November 15, 2018 Posted November 15, 2018 There were still plenty of Unsu and Superimpi. Just not in the finals. Shimizu from Japan did Shitoryu throughout the rounds and in the final. However she also did Team kata and they did Shotokan kata throughout. Some Shotokan stylists seems to have picked up the kata Seisan from GenseiRyu. Things may change again when the judging system for kata changes next year.
luv2flyjrn Posted November 15, 2018 Author Posted November 15, 2018 There were still plenty of Unsu and Superimpi. Just not in the finals. Shimizu from Japan did Shitoryu throughout the rounds and in the final. However she also did Team kata and they did Shotokan kata throughout. Some Shotokan stylists seems to have picked up the kata Seisan from GenseiRyu. Things may change again when the judging system for kata changes next year.How is judging expected to change next year? I haven't followed wkf to closely but will be taking a few students to some of the Midwest competitions. Are the changes on usankf yet? Thank you. Rank does not matter. If you can't learn from a white belt you are probably not deserving a black belt.
wayneshin Posted November 16, 2018 Posted November 16, 2018 There were still plenty of Unsu and Superimpi. Just not in the finals. Shimizu from Japan did Shitoryu throughout the rounds and in the final. However she also did Team kata and they did Shotokan kata throughout. Some Shotokan stylists seems to have picked up the kata Seisan from GenseiRyu. Things may change again when the judging system for kata changes next year.How is judging expected to change next year? I haven't followed wkf to closely but will be taking a few students to some of the Midwest competitions. Are the changes on usankf yet? Thank you.7 judges. Separate scores for technical and athletic performance (the flag system will be gone). It will be in effect from Jan 1 2019 and introduced at the Paris Open in Jan. . The Chairs of the five continental referees commissions will attend a briefing at that event. What will be interesting is how regional events implement it.
luv2flyjrn Posted November 16, 2018 Author Posted November 16, 2018 There were still plenty of Unsu and Superimpi. Just not in the finals. Shimizu from Japan did Shitoryu throughout the rounds and in the final. However she also did Team kata and they did Shotokan kata throughout. Some Shotokan stylists seems to have picked up the kata Seisan from GenseiRyu. Things may change again when the judging system for kata changes next year.How is judging expected to change next year? I haven't followed wkf to closely but will be taking a few students to some of the Midwest competitions. Are the changes on usankf yet? Thank you.7 judges. Separate scores for technical and athletic performance (the flag system will be gone). It will be in effect from Jan 1 2019 and introduced at the Paris Open in Jan. . The Chairs of the five continental referees commissions will attend a briefing at that event. What will be interesting is how regional events implement it.Hmm, so back to something similar to the old scoring system. Head to head scoring or total scoring in a group? I haven't check the wkf or usankf sites yet but are the rules now published there? Thank you. Rank does not matter. If you can't learn from a white belt you are probably not deserving a black belt.
wayneshin Posted November 17, 2018 Posted November 17, 2018 There were still plenty of Unsu and Superimpi. Just not in the finals. Shimizu from Japan did Shitoryu throughout the rounds and in the final. However she also did Team kata and they did Shotokan kata throughout. Some Shotokan stylists seems to have picked up the kata Seisan from GenseiRyu. Things may change again when the judging system for kata changes next year.How is judging expected to change next year? I haven't followed wkf to closely but will be taking a few students to some of the Midwest competitions. Are the changes on usankf yet? Thank you.7 judges. Separate scores for technical and athletic performance (the flag system will be gone). It will be in effect from Jan 1 2019 and introduced at the Paris Open in Jan. . The Chairs of the five continental referees commissions will attend a briefing at that event. What will be interesting is how regional events implement it.Hmm, so back to something similar to the old scoring system. Head to head scoring or total scoring in a group? I haven't check the wkf or usankf sites yet but are the rules now published there? Thank you.It’s not on the WKF site yet. I had this appear on my newsfeed less than an hour ago so I’ve just taken my first look at it.https://karateyalgomas.com/2018/11/16/kata-and-kumite-competition-rules-for-2019/ In a lot of ways in operation it’s going to be similar to the old system.
sensei8 Posted November 18, 2018 Posted November 18, 2018 Excellent conversations, luv2flyjrn, wayneshin, and ineluki; I've enjoyed it a lot!! **Proof is on the floor!!!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now