mya Posted June 20, 2006 Posted June 20, 2006 I think it would be the best tool for an experienced MA, one that would know of its limitations and would not stop doing live training.Who knows maybe in the future you would have dojos with one of thoses.After all the same can be said about the wooden dummy, or a punch bag.Sure bags dont hit back but they teatch you insigtfull lessons on punching.
bushido_man96 Posted June 20, 2006 Posted June 20, 2006 They do have simulator things kind of like this for Law Enforcement Officer training. My dad was telling me about one he was playing around with. No, it is not a substitute for all other officer training, but it is a good supplementation. https://www.haysgym.comhttp://www.sunyis.com/https://www.aikidoofnorthwestkansas.com
greenbelt_girl15 Posted June 21, 2006 Posted June 21, 2006 I think that it would definatly be interesting to have something like a holodeck but only for practicing on your own instead of replacing instructors. I just don't think that a machine could replace a sensei. God has not given us a spirit of fear, but a spirit of love, a spirit of power, and of self-discipline.2 Timothy 1:7
kikr Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 I think it may prove to be a good reinforcement training aid once the technologies advanced. I don't believe it would be a good instructional platform though. It definately could not replace the wisdom of a good sensei. We sleep safe in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm. George Orwell
patusai Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 If the Halodeck is real life situations and since I believe that you can die on the Halodeck unless you end the program then the training on it would be pretty much as good as the programer...provided that the master programed it and the halodeck had the ability to be totally intelligent. Just my thoughts. As for kata, there would never be any doubt as to the authenticity and accuracy of it (unless of course something new was able to be programmed into it ... they would need to lock out any ability to change that part of the program. "Don't tell me the sky's the limit because I have seen footprints on the moon!" -- Paul Brandt
Triskel Posted June 30, 2006 Posted June 30, 2006 The idea is somehow nice, bot holograms represent images only, not phisical stuff... I'd ratter use the training as in Frank Herbert's DUNE... using machines... LOL -------------------------Karate ni sente nashi
bat in a birdless village Posted June 30, 2006 Author Posted June 30, 2006 The idea is somehow nice, bot holograms represent images only, not phisical stuff... I'd ratter use the training as in Frank Herbert's DUNE... using machines... LOLActually, on the Star Trek holodeck, the images can kill you (if you turn the safeties off), so physically it would be identical to a real fight. You could "kill" or actually be killed yourself.My question centered on whether the martial arts community or society would recognize someone as an experienced martial artist if they got all of their training in a holo-simulator like that one.bat Being a shodan is about learning what you DON'T know about what you know.
Menjo Posted June 30, 2006 Posted June 30, 2006 My question centered on whether the martial arts community or society would recognize someone as an experienced martial artist if they got all of their training in a holo-simulator like that one.batPerhaps make a poll?But I know I would not recognize someone who trained purly in a simulator, thats for sure. "Time is what we want most, but what we use worst"William Penn
Aodhan Posted July 1, 2006 Posted July 1, 2006 Well, if you encompass everything that the holodeck is supposed to be, then yes, I believe it could be an effective sensei and produce a legitimate black belt.Don't forget that the holodeck can not only create appropriate level opponents, but the AI of the computer is advanced enough that it can learn and adapt, and force the student to learn and improve.I don't think it would be adaptible enough to produce an advanced rank black belt, but a competent 1st degree, sure.Aodhan There are some people who live in a dream world, and there are some who face reality; and then there are those who turn one into the other.-Douglas Everett, American hockey player
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now