Yasutsune Makoto Posted July 4, 2006 Posted July 4, 2006 I love the bunkai to nijushiho and jitte...they make me smile. Gi, Yu, Rei, Jin, Makoto, Melyo, Chugo
css1971 Posted July 6, 2006 Posted July 6, 2006 My question is this. Do you train in bunkai in your school? If so, how often and do you feel you do too little, just enough or too much?Every class.kata -> bunkai -> kumite (of various types from punching and kicking to rolling about on the floor.)Obviously with lower grades, simpler and arguably more effective techniques. I think one of the aspects is to teach the independant analysis of kata. A lot of clubs have broken the link between kata and kumite, which is a shame, it devalues the art.If you think you don't do enough bunkai, or don't link it to kumite there's a book you should read. Actually, it's a book every karateka should read.Bunkai Jutsu: Ian Abernethy The Karate Wiki: Information about karate written by karate practioners... Yes, that means you!
css1971 Posted July 6, 2006 Posted July 6, 2006 We have more than 130 something bunkai, and I would say a good 75% of those are not found in our kata.I'm not sure that makes sense, bunkai is the analysis of kata. It's a search. The Karate Wiki: Information about karate written by karate practioners... Yes, that means you!
RichardHangHong Posted July 6, 2006 Author Posted July 6, 2006 If you think you don't do enough bunkai, or don't link it to kumite there's a book you should read. Actually, it's a book every karateka should read.Bunkai Jutsu: Ian AbernethyYes, Bunkai-Jutsu is a fantastic read. I just finished reading it a few weeks ago. It took me a while to read the whole thing as I have such a busy schedule and am not the greatest reader in the world. I tried reading at night but it kept me awake thinking about all the different ideas it gave me. I'm now reading Aiden Trimble's Karate Kata Applications and Funakoshi's 20 Guiding Principles. Richard Hang HongChief InstructorSeitou Ryu KarateFind me on Facebook!Seitou Ryu Karate
css1971 Posted July 6, 2006 Posted July 6, 2006 Yes, Bunkai-Jutsu is a fantastic read. I just finished reading it a few weeks ago. It took me a while to read the whole thing as I have such a busy schedule and am not the greatest reader in the world. I tried reading at night but it kept me awake thinking about all the different ideas it gave me. I have to be honest, it completely revolutionised the way I look at and practice karate. He also has an excellent set of articles on his web site which everyone should read even if they don't have the book or videos.http://www.iainabernethy.com/articles/BasicBunkaiPart1.aspIt has 6 parts so far.Another which is worth reading for more advanced practitioners is a book by Bill Burgar called Five Years One Kata. It's hmm, radical. Recommending that we each develop our own kata from the favourite techniqes we've learned. The Karate Wiki: Information about karate written by karate practioners... Yes, that means you!
Fu Man Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 I believe that bunkai is an essential part of karate training as it helps the transition from kata to kumite/applied techniques for self defence as well as helping one to understand just what it is we are doing in our respective katas.I totally agree with you.At the dojo where I train, bunkai is trained quite often. I would estimate, at least, once a week, with 3 classes held per week. After a kata is learnt, the student begins to learn the bunkai principles behind the movements and techniques. This process starts at the lower ranks, and continues through the advance rankings.
bbk2132 Posted July 22, 2006 Posted July 22, 2006 We do a lot a bunkai in our dojobut we do more then just thatwe also do sparring of sorts were we are supposed to use a certain bunkai or variation.We do a lot of bunkai variations that are still the same movements only slightly different and in a different context.My sensei works hard to make sure we see how kata can be applied to real fighting. "good enough is the enemy of excellence"Shodan Goju Ryu karate-do under Sensei Gene Villa
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now