three60roundhouse Posted February 20, 2002 Posted February 20, 2002 There have been many disputes over the years as to at what age the black belt should be given to kids, at what age kids start training, at what age they are mature enough to grasp the meaning of the martial arts, etc.On 2002-02-16 14:09, Angus wrote: The meaining of black belt's been lost, it's not something that's given to kids. Hmmm....I don't know. What's a "kid"? And aren't some kids more mature than some adults, and vice versa? What do you guys think? 1st dan Tae Kwon DoYellow Belt Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu16 Years OldGirls kick butt!
SaiFightsMS Posted February 20, 2002 Posted February 20, 2002 Check out the thread should young kids do the martial arts.
Bon Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 (edited) ::edit:: Edited September 29, 2002 by Bon It takes sacrifice to be the best.There are always two choices, two paths to take. One is easy. And its only reward is that it's easy.
Ryukyu1 Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 I don't like the idea of a young child holding a black belt. I understand some instructors will defend this by saying that the progress the kids in order to keep them motivated. For me this just doesn't wash. There are other ways of motivating kids and helping them to progress then giving them belts like candy. Long term this just devalues the rank and lessens any real sense of achievement.
Phantasmatic Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 For us we cannot give a a legal child a black belt. You must be 18 years of age before we give anyone a black belt. I know many people that are in TKD and are taught by 8-10 year olds. They all quit! (I mean no disrespect to the art of TKD, I was in it!) "Which one is more foolish, the fool or the fool who follows him?" - Obi Wan Kenobi
three60roundhouse Posted February 21, 2002 Author Posted February 21, 2002 Here's another thing: the junior black belt. So many studios (including mine) are awarding these to children UNDER age 16 when they've met all the requirements for a first dan, but are not emotionally mature enough for a black belt. The belt is half black and half red, and the junior black belts learn the same forms and stuff as the regular first dans, but they have to re-test for their black belts at age 16. I think this system is good....it shows the child that they HAVE accompolished a lot, but also reminds them that they aren't as mature as the older black belts and that they still have a long way to go. 1st dan Tae Kwon DoYellow Belt Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu16 Years OldGirls kick butt!
Phantasmatic Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 360, that is probably the best way to go about it because it makes the children think, ya know. I really wish we had those at our dojo, my sensei doesn't get out much. Maybe I should tell him about that! "Which one is more foolish, the fool or the fool who follows him?" - Obi Wan Kenobi
three60roundhouse Posted February 21, 2002 Author Posted February 21, 2002 I know that telling a six year old who is passionate about the martial arts that it'll take him twelve years to be at black belt while a sixteen year old who starts only needs four or five might turn many a future star off. 1st dan Tae Kwon DoYellow Belt Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu16 Years OldGirls kick butt!
Cory Reynolds Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 I like the idea of the junior black belt also. Telling a kid that they won't be able to earn their full black belt until the age of at least 16-18 would sound discoraging. But then you have to follow it up with reasons why, and how the study of the martial arts is about so much more than just earning belts anyways. By the time that they reach the rank of junior black belt, they should have developed the maturity to at least understand and accept the waiting period. Wise man once said "he who has big mouth has much room for foot."
kicker Posted February 21, 2002 Posted February 21, 2002 well which is said before i think kids that are under a certain age lets say 16-18 only get a junier black belt and just keep on training intil 16-18 and then they can get the black belt. I personaly like that idea and it should be used and you should be able to instructed a class after your 18 or like 21. which you get a belt for or something when you do your best it`s going to show. "If you watch the pros, You will learn something new"
Recommended Posts