How important ?

[fangshi]

How important ?

As the martial arts of this era expand ever so rapidly , how important do you feel the philosophy of the martial arts is ? There are so many different methodologies of teaching , do you feel that it is important to also teach the bushido or Buddhist or Taoist ideals as well as the fundamentals of combat ?

Do you feel that these ideals help you grow as a martial artist and a person ?

Do you feel that schools that do not teach these ideals should , or vice versa ?

I was just wondering if students from different schools had different outlooks on this topic , so if your style is not listed in your info could you please post .

[BDelich]

Hi Fangshi:

I personally think it is very important to have a philosophy wound in with martial arts training. While in college I did a lot of research into the effects of martial srts trainng on people and here are some basics of what I found:

Folks who trained in an art that had no philosophy or ethical code actually became more aggressive and more likely to use their art in a negative way. They also suffered from more emotional issues.

Folks who trained in an art that had a strong ethical/moral component became more peaceful and comfortable with themselves as well as others.

I think it is a good idea to always have a balance in anything you do. As part of their training young samurai had to learn calligraphy, art of tea, bonsai, or ibuki (flower art). These things were to help calm their spirit after training in martial arts all of the time. A way to help balance out the psyche.

As far as the Bushido, Buddhist, Taoist, or whatever ideals I don't think it matters as long as they are of a variety that would help calm one's spirit and allow for a place of respect for self and others.

Do you feel that these ideals help you grow as a martial artist and a person ?

Definately. Most of the ideals found in the Philosophies/ Religions that you mention help one find peace within. In then end, I really do belive martial arts can do this for people who train in them. Having an art that develops you physically, mentally, and spiritually will really help improve the quality of your life as well as those around you.

Do you feel that schools that do not teach these ideals should , or vice versa ?

When one person or group dictates what another group should or should not do, problems arise. Some people are drawn to these things and other people are turned off by them. So I actually think we need both.

Ben

[dtstiachi]

Great post ben, welcome to KF

[granmasterchen]

nicely said