karatekid1975 Posted July 27, 2004 Posted July 27, 2004 I agree with TangSooGuy and TSDMGK_K40. I did TSD. Now I do TKD after moving to NY. I find that TKD is geared more toward kicks. TSD has more hand techs (at least my old dojang taught it that way). Laurie F
tommarker Posted July 27, 2004 Posted July 27, 2004 In class, I tend to drill at about 60%kick/40%hand. However, the hyung are about 80/20 in favor of the hands. In sparring, I see a lot of people who spar 80/20 in favor of the feet, though I tend to favor close range, and I'm about 60% hands. I've seen some schools that are very kick oriented, and other schools which are more upper body work... Most of those guys tend to come from Shotokan backgrounds or were boxers. They also tend to be big guys... though I know a few "big guys" who can do jump spinning kicks quite gracefully. I'm no longer posting here. Adios.
Disciple Posted July 28, 2004 Author Posted July 28, 2004 Jlee, to answer directly. No, it isn't all legs/prettymuch all legs. It is far more balanced than TKD in that aspect.
ShunGokuSatsu Posted August 1, 2004 Posted August 1, 2004 I'm an orange belt in Tang Soo Do. I live in the south in a town that isn't even on 3/4 of the maps we study at school but is named after a hero Kosciusko.
Disciple Posted August 8, 2004 Author Posted August 8, 2004 It is great to see the turn out and the replies from all the artists. Keep posting guys and gals. Keep asking questions. For example, who knows Pat Johnson and what his contribution to our art is?
tommarker Posted August 9, 2004 Posted August 9, 2004 TURTLE POWER, BABY!! I'm no longer posting here. Adios.
Mu Ryuk Posted August 12, 2004 Posted August 12, 2004 6th Gup from Monterey, California. Hyungs: Gichu Hyung Il Bu Gichu Hyung Il Bu Sum Gup Gichu Hyung E Bu Gichu Hyung E Bu Sum Gup Gichu Hyung Sam Bu Pyung-Ahn Cho Dan Pyung-Ahn E Dan Pyung-Ahn Sam Dan Pyung-Ahn Sah Dan Pyung-Ahn O Dan Bassai, form of the Cobra. Nahachi Cho Dan Nahachi E Dan Nahachi Sam Dan Jin Do I'm not sure past that...our Instructor knows everything up to (I believe) 6th Dan, but has to drive about 12 hours to test, so is still a Cho Dan. We're trying to talk him into testing though Mr.Durney (Head Instructor) concentrates more on kicking, but in Mr.Beeson's classes we get to do a lot of Boxing-like drills, so we get our hand work in. Mr.Rienecker is a technique freak, which is a great thing to do once a week or so. I think in some ways we are a bit McDojoish, but our prices are more than reasonable ( $65.00 a month for as many classes as you want to take) and while the kids classes could be more serious our students are (most of them anyway) quite good, and the adult class is quite good. While Mr.Durney and Mr.Beeson are both quite good at point sparring, our school is better known for our Forms in tournaments. Tang Soo! Passion transcends pain.
Disciple Posted August 13, 2004 Author Posted August 13, 2004 Mu Ryuk, Do you only practice one Bassai form? or both Bassai So and Bassai Dae?
TKDCat Posted August 21, 2004 Posted August 21, 2004 I am originally from Tae-Kwon-Do, but my master left. Being in a small town there isn't much here, so I coudln't just switch to another Tae-Kwon-Do school. I'm going to be 16 in about 48 days...along with getting my lisence! Watch out! Anyway, I got into Tang-Soo-Do in March? Something like that. I don't know a lot of the forms or anything. I'm starting in the basics with my friend who is starting completely from scratch. I don't believe my master is wanting to teach me the Mudikwan(sp? Sorry if that isn't spelled right!) style of forms, because I'm originally a Tae-Kwon-Do student with the rank of 2nd Dan. I did ask him about him teaching them to me. I don't believe there will be any good TKD masters coming around here anytime soon, which I don't have a problem with. I like TSD, because it uses more punching then TKD does. I'm also teaching my new master about the "new" sparring style, he is very interested in it. All of his students are amazed with me, because of my kicks and speed. I think that he is also hoping that I will help to encourage the process of speed and technique in the dojang. I am more than happy to do this. I love to art, and if I can help others love it just as much, I will do what I can! I'm hoping that I can learn the new forms that are there for me to learn, and add my "grace" to them. That's what I've heard from many people about my forms and kicks. Who knows! At my school we don't have certian self defense one-steps. The Master shows us more and more with almost every class, but they are not numbered. Whereas in TKD, we had 30 one steps. My new master has probably showed me 30 or more NEW ones. He is very educated in the one steps, and knows a lot of them, and has even encouraged me using ones I know, and mixing them up into new ones. He has also spent time teaching me one steps that I use my kicks in, since that is my speciality. I think that I like the more traditional style, compared to the sport style. I do miss sparring though. Nothing can replace that feeling! I am learning more of the Korean terms with a Hesipanic(sp?) Master then I did with a true Korean master. I think that's a but messed up, but oh well. KittyCat=^;^=2nd Dan-Tae-Kwon-Do
Recommended Posts