Thanks for the advise. As far as half ranks, there are half ranks between every rank. So if I am 3rd kyu and test a half rank I would be 2b. It would take another half to be a 2 kyu or full brown with one stripe. I guess it is a way to give some type of progress instead of just failing people and making them retest the same thing later. It's not my instructor that does the testing but a senior instructor. It doesn't seem like he is telling my instructor what it is that I am doing wrong. I get the same thing after my test, the same generic response to what I am doing wrong. Just seems like there is more but maybe I am reading into it too much. I am going to try to attend classes with the senior instructor once a month. He teaches in a town that is an hour away so its hard to do regularly but maybe if I go every once in a while he will notice and maybe help me out a little during the classes.