Everyone has made good points. But I think that if the person has truly learned what they need to learn and they have the right attitude, and they of course pass testing requirements, then they should become a balck belt. I became a black belt when I was 10 years old. It took me about 2.5 years to get my first dan. Like Heather Smyth said, I don't get special treatment because I'm young. If they're/you're not ready to have the belt, then you should wait to give/recieve a black belt. But if the person is ready, then they shouldn't be denied the great opportunity. >Britt