Jump to content
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt

jasonis

Members
  • Posts

    5
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jasonis

  1. What? Does that ever happen? I've never heard of or witnessed a beginner being expected to spar before they're ready. Never. That's not to say it doesn't happen. I've never known it or heard of it. Is that something that happens in the US? Quite apart from it being morally wrong to ask a new starter to spare before they're ready, it would also be dangerous not just for the new starter, but for the other students. What if the new kid is both completely mental and extremely tough? Are there really instructors out there that would take that risk before getting to know and trust the new starter? Then there's the civil liability. The new person is effectively a guest. Are are there any insurance companies out there that are happy to cover clubs that throw visitors to the wolves? Unfortunately it still happens, but hopefully very, very rarely. That was the norm when my former and current teacher started. It wasn’t the norm, it it was still around when I first started in ‘94. I sparred my first night. Both of them shake their heads and say “yeah, we don’t do that anymore.” Too many hard lessons learned. It’s an extreme example, and highly unlikely the OP will be subjected to it. In fact, I really hesitated to mention it at all. My main point was to watch and see what’s going on before jumping in. What if he works out with them, then realizes they’re a bare knuckle/full contact school? Even if he’s not allowed to spar that night or until he’s genuinely ready, what if he wants no part of that type of sparring? He’s spent the night working out in a dojo he’ll never join. What if he starts working out with them, then they break out into a chi ball no-touch knockout session? There’s an hour of his life he’ll never get back. Another extreme example. My main realistic point is watch what’s going on before you get on the floor. Haha, I am pretty much up for most things, bare knuckle would not bother me at all, a chi ball no knockout session might be a huge turn off though! xD It's described as "Shotokai" which i think is the same as shotokan? I am going Friday and i wondered whether or not i should research about the art some more first? the only experience i have of karate is seeing lyot machida and wonderboy in the ufc also a lot of videos posted to social media platforms the reason i chose karate is because it looks like an awesome style, i'd say possibly the best defensively and in terms of counter attacking, I hope i'd never have to use it and i doubt i ever will but yeah those are my reasons.
  2. Hi there, I haven't started MA yet but will go to a local shotokan club this week,so im no expert of course, I do however believe whilst we should place our full trust in a teacher (for anything, not exclusive to MA) you can't be so gullible to think anything, anytime will work there are so many circumstances where things just don't work so whilst I agree they shouldn't be teaching them "This will work every time" but rather "This is the most likely to work in this situation". Another thing i'd like to discuss is the " their techniques will have no effect whatsoever because they've only ever trained against a fully compliant partner." part because I'd hate to find myself in a situation and rely on a false sense of security, in other words how would you utilise your MA in the best way possible, and know you were actually able to defend yourself? One more thing, maybe this needs a thread but I see a lot of people say they don't train for the self defence it just comes along with the rest of it, my second priority after fitness is self defence... if anyone could shed some light on what i should focus on that would be great because i'd hate to start for all of the wrong reasons.
  3. Thank you for your replies, I am going to go next week 15 minutes early and get in a chat with them, hopefully I can jump straight in and give it a go! but will settle for watching if they wish
  4. What is TABE? thank you
  5. Hello all, I've been wanting to start Karate so i decided to message my local club (only one in the area) I sent a message over explaining i'm a bit overweight and completely useless cardio-wise having been in active for about 4 years (my bad) anyway I sent that almost two weeks ago and no reply so i'm wondering if they maybe didn't get it or something else, what should I do? should I just turn up? I'm completely nervous about starting tbh so just turning up feels a bit uncomfortable, should i just bite the bullet? sorry for rambling on haha Any advice welcome, thank you. Jason
×
×
  • Create New...